Competing technologies quickly followed using a variety of materials, including non-resins, and today, designers have a selection of rapid prototyping options at their disposal. Popular non-resin 3D printing technologies include fused deposition modelling (FDM), selective laser sintering (SLS), and Multi Jet Fusion (MJF), as well as several newer SLA variants. The question then becomes: Which one is best for my application?
What is Resin 3D Printing?
Resin 3D printing is an umbrella term used to describe additive manufacturing technologies that build parts from a liquid photopolymer resin that hardens or “cures” when exposed to a light source.
Conversely, filament-based printers like FDM melt a spool of plastic filament feedstock to create parts layer-by-layer, while powder-based printers (SLS and MJF) fuse powder particles using a laser, fusing agents, or other heat source.
We’ll explore the details behind the different resin-based processes shortly, but all share some common attributes. Chief among them are higher resolution and finer part details compared to filament or powder printers, with less of the “stair-stepping” common to 3D printing. This is due to precise control of the light source and the ability to generate thinner layers, thus leaving smoother finishes than the alternatives. In addition, these parts require less post-processing than those made via the other methods, reducing part cost and improving accuracy.
Because of this, resin-based 3D printing is often the preferred method for parts with intricate designs, as well as small or miniature parts and those with fine features. Some prototype and low-volume uses cases for stereolithography include:
- Patient-specific surgical guides
- Dental aligners
- Jewellery moulds and patterns
- Knobs and covers for automotive use
- Electronic housings
How Do Different Resin 3D Printers Work?
Despite its many uses and applications, it’s important to understand the mechanics behind the different types of resin-based 3D printing. Here’s a brief outline of some of the available technologies, followed by some considerations for each:
Stereolithography (SLA)
The grandfather of additive manufacturing, SLA has not sat on its 3D-printed laurels during the past 40 years, and today’s machines are much faster and more accurate than their predecessors. That said, all rely on an ultraviolet (UV) laser to trace the outline and interior of each layer, curing the liquid resin as it goes. Once each “slice” is complete, the build platform drops slightly, fresh resin is pulled across the cured surface, and the process repeats until the build is complete. Again, very fine detail is possible, albeit at lower speeds than the other resin-based processes.
PolyJet
Imagine an inkjet printer that, instead of ink, deposits a liquid photopolymer resin onto a build tray; and with the completion of each layer, a UV light passes overhead, curing the resin. PolyJet is one of the few AM technologies that supports multiple types of material in a single build, including a wax-like support material that is washed away from the finished workpiece once it leaves the build chamber. This capability allows designers to create prototypes that combine two colours or durometers (hardness), making it ideal for flexible parts like gaskets and seals.
Materials Used in Resin 3D Printing
These printers can also process resins that exhibit diverse properties, allowing them to be used in a wide range of applications. Among them are soft and squishy silicone-like materials, resins that become hard and heat-resistant like ceramic when cured, general-purpose workhorse resins that mimic ABS or polypropylene (PP), and polycarbonate-like resins that deliver clear or translucent parts with a high stiffness. By comparison, non-resin SLS and MJF printers are mainly limited to nylon and PP, while FDM can print a variety of thermoplastic materials, albeit at nowhere near the accuracy or speed of its competitors.
It's important to note that resins require careful storage, typically away from light and at controlled temperatures. And because they contain volatile organic compounds (VOCs), they must be used in well-ventilated areas, and contact with human skin should also be avoided.
Resins are generally more expensive than filament and powder and are often proprietary to the 3D printer manufacturer. But given the variety of available materials and robust physical characteristics, the cost delta is often secondary to product performance.
Comparing Industrial and Desktop Resin 3D Printers
Those reading this might look at the relatively low cost of desktop printers and wonder: why not take control of our prototyping destiny and buy our own machine? That's certainly possible and some companies have done just that, although many have quickly come to realise that industrial-grade printers typically provide higher precision and smoother surface finishes, not to mention significantly greater speed and build volumes.
Industrial printers also offer a more comprehensive material selection than desktop machines. This is likely not a huge differentiator for basic prototype work, but where functional testing is concerned, getting as close to the end-use material as possible is critical. And again, whatever resins are used must be stored properly and consumed within their limited shelf life.
But perhaps the biggest reason to “go industrial” is experience. One example of this comes from Daniel Lubiner, a special education teacher working with blind and low-vision children, who ran into problems taking his BrailleDoodle design from paper to prototype. After investing in several iterations that didn’t meet the device’s accuracy or surface finish requirements, he turned to us for help. The 3D printing team used industrial SLA to manufacture the prototype’s three main components from ABS-like plastic, some of which have features as small as 0.0508mm.
Another example? Medical device startup UVision360 leveraged micro-resolution SLA and MicroFine Green thermoset resin from Protolabs to build miniature parts for its Luminelle hysteroscopy system. Doing so helped the small company avoid roughly £200,000 in tooling costs and shaved months off the development cycle.
In these and other cases, the companies could have assumed that investing a few thousand pounds in a desktop SLA printer would be “good enough” for their prototyping purposes. They would be wrong, however; as many novice users have found, there’s much more to successful 3D printing than the equipment, and it’s only through extensive experience and no small amount of trial by fire that companies master this deeply technical process.
Outsourced vs. In-house 3D-Printing: Side-by-Side Comparison
| | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Outsourced 3D Printing | - More processes and materials available
- Greater production capacity
| - Potentially longer lead time
- Higher unit price
|
| In-house 3D Printing | - Convenient
- No need to wait for a quote
- Fastest part delivery
| - Limited in terms of part quality and accuracy, and material selection
- Workplace environmental considerations
- Upfront investment in machines
|
Post-Processing for Resin 3D Prints
Resin-based 3D printing technologies share several additional commonalities. Chief among them is the need for build supports, which must be removed after printing. As suggested earlier, support removal with the PolyJet process can be quite simple—just wash the parts—whereas SLA parts require a bit more effort, namely breaking away the supports and using a little sandpaper to smooth the resultant nub.
Other potential post-processing options include vapour smoothing, dyeing, decaling, painting, and texturing, all of which are also available with Protolabs' other polymer 3D printing services. Note that not all of these finishing options are available for every printing process.
In summary, each of these resin-based 3D printing processes delivers high-quality parts with fine details and superior accuracy—the decision as to which one is most appropriate for your application depends on numerous factors, among them part size, quantity, material availability, and numerous other considerations that are best reviewed with one of our 3D printing experts.Email us at customerservice@protolabs.co.uk or call +44 (0) 1952 683047.